Pizza Across Milwaukee & Waukesha Counties

National Pizza Day - Monday, February 9

Pizza nights aren’t just about dinner — they’re about the places we keep going back to. The corner spot everyone knows, the one that becomes part of the routine, and the place that somehow always feels like the right choice when no one wants to cook. Some people judge a neighborhood by the schools or the commute. Others judge it by the pizza.

As real estate professionals, The Hupke Team spends a lot of time getting to know neighborhoods beyond the listings - and local pizza places tend to tell you a lot. They’re part of everyday life, woven into weeknights, weekends, and long-standing local traditions.

So in celebration of National Pizza Day on Monday, February 9, we’ve put together a guide to pizza spots across Milwaukee and Waukesha Counties. Whether you’re loyal to your usual order or looking for a new favorite, consider this your excuse to have a pizza night.

Milwaukee County

Cudahy

Papa Luigi’s Pizza
5655 S Packard Ave, Cudahy, WI 53110
Papa Luigi’s has been a Cudahy landmark since 1982, known for classic pizza and Italian comfort food served in a relaxed, family-focused setting. Built on consistency, quality, and a strong sense of hospitality, it has earned a loyal following and remains a dependable neighborhood staple.

Milwaukee

San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana
838 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI 53203
San Giorgio specializes in Neapolitan-style pizza prepared using traditional Italian methods while incorporating locally sourced ingredients. The menu balances authenticity and place, producing pizzas that respect their Italian roots while fitting naturally into Milwaukee’s dining scene.

Santino’s Little Italy
352 E Stewart St, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Santino’s focuses on ingredient-driven pizza made with Caputo 00 flour, Grande mozzarella, and San Marzano tomatoes. Pizzas are cooked using cherry wood sourced from northern Wisconsin, adding depth to each pie. Patio seating is available, and reservations are strongly recommended.

Fixture Pizza Pub
623 S 2nd St, Milwaukee, WI 53204
Located in Walker’s Point, Fixture Pizza Pub offers creative pizzas in an industrial-style pub setting. A rotating craft beer selection complements the menu, making it a popular spot for casual dinners, meetups, and relaxed nights out.

Saint Francis

Barbiere’s Italian Inn
5842 S Packard Ave, Saint Francis, WI 53235
Barbiere’s Italian Inn is an old-school Italian-American restaurant known for thin-crust pizza, pasta, and classic supper-club fare. The familiar menu and traditional atmosphere have made it a reliable local gathering place for years.

West Allis

Flour Girl & Flame
8121 W National Ave, West Allis, WI 53214
Flour Girl & Flame is a casual neighborhood spot specializing in wood-fired pizza and creative seasonal dishes. Thoughtful preparation and a relaxed atmosphere make it an easy choice for both everyday meals and casual nights out.

Nico’s Authentic Premium Pizza
9638 W National Ave, West Allis, WI 53227
Nico’s serves premium pizza with a focus on fresh ingredients and consistent execution. The menu leans into classic styles, making it a dependable option for familiar, well-made pizza.

Wauwatosa

Balistreri’s Italian-American Ristorante
812 N 68th St, Wauwatosa, WI 53213
Balistreri’s offers thin-crust pizza and traditional Italian-American dishes in a cozy, nostalgic setting. Known for its lively, family-friendly atmosphere, it remains a longtime favorite for casual meals and group gatherings.

Waukesha County

Brookfield

The Red Mill Inn & Pizza
1005 S Elm Grove Rd, Brookfield, WI 53005
Housed in a building dating back to 1847, The Red Mill Inn pairs tavern-style thin-crust pizza with a historic supper-club atmosphere. Its character, consistency, and setting have made it a recognizable local destination.

Villalobos Pizzeria
2205 N Calhoun Rd, Brookfield, WI 53005
Villalobos Pizzeria is a cozy restaurant specializing in homemade pizza and Italian dishes. Highly rated for fresh ingredients, it focuses on balanced flavors and straightforward preparation in a comfortable neighborhood setting.

Delafield

Giuseppe’s Pizzeria
615 Main St, Delafield, WI 53018
Giuseppe’s is known for thin-crust pizza made with whole-milk Wisconsin mozzarella and a slightly sweeter sauce. Specialty pies and classic options are served in a relaxed downtown environment.

Marty’s Pizza
2580 Sun Valley Dr, Delafield, WI 53018
Tracing its roots back to 1957, Marty’s Pizza is built on long-standing recipes, premium flour dough, and original marinara. Its consistency and history have earned it a loyal, multi-generational following.

Hartland

The Inn at Hartland
110 Cottonwood Ave, Hartland, WI 53029
The Inn at Hartland serves wood-fired pizza alongside seasonal dishes prepared with care. The welcoming atmosphere encourages shared meals and makes it a comfortable place to gather.

Falbo Bros Pizzeria
418 Merton Ave, Hartland, WI 53029
Falbo Bros features a proprietary pizza style developed from family recipes, with dough and sauce prepared in-house. The focus remains on approachable flavors and consistent preparation.

Hubertus

Carol Ann’s Pizza
2935 Hubertus Rd, Hubertus, WI 53033
Carol Ann’s Pizza is a family-owned pizzeria using Grande mozzarella, preservative-free sausage, and dough made fresh daily. Par-bake options allow customers to enjoy their pizza at home.

Menomonee Falls

De Marinis Pizzeria
N88W15229 Main St, Menomonee Falls, WI 53051
De Marinis specializes in Wisconsin-style butter-crust bar pizza served in a casual, full-bar setting. It’s known locally for consistency and a relaxed, familiar atmosphere.

Pepino’s Pizza & Ristorante
N84W15841 Appleton Ave, Menomonee Falls, WI 53051
Pepino’s is a family-owned Italian restaurant offering classic pizza and traditional Italian dishes in a warm, inviting setting. Fresh ingredients, traditional techniques, and an old-world feel define the experience.

Mukwonago

Crazy Bears Pizza Company
101 Lake St, Mukwonago, WI 53149
Crazy Bears offers a wide range of crust options, including thin, deep dish, stuffed, and gluten-free. The menu balances creative specialty pizzas with familiar favorites.

Genoa’s Pizza
225 Bay View Rd, Suite 500, Mukwonago, WI 53149
Genoa’s Pizza is a three-generation family business rooted in Italian heritage. The focus remains on straightforward preparation, consistency, and time-tested recipes.

New Berlin

Armeli’s Restaurant & Pizzeria
16201 W National Ave, New Berlin, WI 53151
Armeli’s serves Italian-American and Italian dishes with a familiar, house-made touch. Alongside its well-known pizza, the menu includes crowd favorites and Wisconsin staples like Friday Night Fish Fry, paired with generous portions and welcoming hospitality.

Oconomowoc

Twisted Fire
515 E Wisconsin Ave, Oconomowoc, WI 53066
Twisted Fire uses a high-temperature stone oven to produce wood-fired pizza in an upscale-casual environment. The menu extends beyond pizza while maintaining a focus on quality and balance.

Bella Gusto Italian Deli & Pizzeria
29 S Main St, Oconomowoc, WI 53066
Bella Gusto combines brick-oven pizza and Roman-style pinsa with an Italian deli concept. Traditional flavors, imported ingredients, and a European-inspired approach define the menu.

Eric’s Hand Tossed Pizza & Subs
1280 Brown St, Oconomowoc, WI 53066
Eric’s is a family-run, locally owned restaurant serving the Lake Country area. Dough is made fresh every morning, and everything is prepared to order using fresh ingredients.

Kim’s Gourmet Pub
N67W33395 County Hwy K, Oconomowoc, WI 53066
Kim’s Gourmet Pub offers thin-crust pub-style pizza with creative topping combinations, supported by a strong craft beer selection and casual atmosphere.

Pewaukee

Doc’s Dry Dock
N38W27091 Parkside Rd, Pewaukee, WI 53072
Doc’s Dry Dock is known for brick-oven, cracker-thin pizza made entirely by hand. Everything is prepared from scratch with a deliberate process that prioritizes quality over speed.

Park Avenue Pizza Company
121 Park Ave, Pewaukee, WI 53072
Located inside a former theater building, Park Avenue Pizza Company serves classic pizza in a family-friendly setting. The historic space adds character to the dining experience.

Sussex

Tony Maronni’s Pizza
N63 W23951 Main St, Sussex, WI 53089
Tony Maronni’s emphasizes artisan dough, quality ingredients, and careful preparation. Guests can dine in or take pizzas home unbaked to finish themselves.

Sal’s Pizza
N64W24370 Main St, Sussex, WI 53089
Sal’s Pizza serves classic pizza, pasta, and sandwiches with a focus on value and familiarity. Daily specials and a relaxed atmosphere keep it a neighborhood staple.

Wales

Pizza Guy
323 N Wales Rd, Wales, WI 53183
Serving the Kettle Moraine area since 1998, Pizza Guy is known for homemade dough perfected over decades and a wide variety of specialty pizzas in a cozy, family-focused setting.

Waukesha

Jimmy’s Grotto
314 E Main St, Waukesha, WI 53186
Operating since August 15, 1946, Jimmy’s Grotto is a Waukesha institution best known for inventing the trademarked Ponza Rotta — a deep-fried calzone filled with sauce, cheese, and pizza toppings. Its no-frills, takeout-focused approach and long history make it a true local landmark.

Magellan’s On Main Street
370 W Main St, Waukesha, WI 53186
Magellan’s pairs specialty pizza with an extensive craft beer selection in a casual, family-friendly setting. The building itself has housed a bar for decades, adding to its neighborhood character.

Billy D’s Pub
1313 Arcadian Ave, Waukesha, WI 53186
Billy D’s centers its menu around a wood-fired pizza oven, producing pizzas known for bold flavor and quality ingredients. Shareable items like cheesy bread and oversized soft pretzels round out the menu.

Michael’s Italian Restaurant
1400 S Grand Ave, Waukesha, WI 53189
Michael’s is a long-established Italian restaurant offering classic Italian-American dishes and pizza in a traditional setting. It is especially known for its extensive wine-by-the-glass selection.

 The Last Slice

Just like finding a great pizza place, finding the right home is about how a place fits into your everyday life. Neighborhoods are shaped by routines, local favorites, and the details that make an area feel familiar.

In 2025, The Hupke Team closed 102 homes totaling over $35 million and earned 135 five-star Google reviews from clients across Southeastern Wisconsin.

So enjoy National Pizza Day, celebrate the local spots that make each community unique, and remember that local experience matters. The Hupke Team is proud to be a trusted resource for buyers and sellers throughout Southeastern Wisconsin.


🍕 Pizza Disclaimer:  Hours of operation may vary, so a quick call ahead is always a good idea. If we missed a favorite, send it our way — there’s always room for more pizza.